If you are thinking about buying some..DON'T DO IT!! Disgusting stuff,imho. I have tried the vanilla ice cream and strawberry and thought it was much better than other brands, but cookies and cream is crap. :( I'm just glad that I bought the 2lb tub instead of the 5lb.

Jason

i heaerd the same about the new flavor. ON is really disappointing me these days with ADENERGY and now this crappy flavor.

If you are thinking about buying some..DON'T DO IT!! Disgusting stuff,imho. I have tried the vanilla ice cream and strawberry and thought it was much better than other brands, but cookies and cream is crap. :( I'm just glad that I bought the 2lb tub instead of the 5lb.

Jason
i almost bought this flavor but decided to try the chocolate and chocolate mint instead. Two thumbs up for both flavors. i tried the vanilla ice cream before and that was good. i have heard others say they don't like the cookies and cream mainly because it's overly sweet. is that why you don't like it?

I bought 5lb!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

What's bad about it is that the aftertaste. It's not that sweet at all. However, I put 1 tps of cocoa in it along with dextrose and/or splenda in it which make it so much better since I have to finish that 5lbs.... that's the only way

i almost bought this flavor but decided to try the chocolate and chocolate mint instead. Two thumbs up for both flavors. i tried the vanilla ice cream before and that was good. i have heard others say they don't like the cookies and cream mainly because it's overly sweet. is that why you don't like it?


Honestly, I don't think it is sweet enough. To me, it tastes more like mint chocolate chip than just plain chocolate chip. Like F1Champ said, the aftertaste is terrible. I'm burping up the taste for a few hours afterwards. I tried putting a banana in it and it made it a little bit better.

Jason

I bought a 5lb ON Choc Mint. I liked it for about a week and then it started to taste worse and worse. I just buy straight up chocolate no matter what brand I buy because I dont seem to get sick of it. All these speciality flavors get old quick.

I like just chocolate but haven't tried any other flavors. Thanks for the heads-up.

I have noticed that the chocolate flavor can vary from batch to batch though. Sometimes it's a really strong chocolate, sometimes it's light with a little bit of a coconut taste to it.

I agree with the others, get only chocolate or vanilla, you can't go wrong with those 2.

That's upsetting. The ON Chocolate Mint is the best whey I've EVER had and I had high expectations of the Cookies n Cream. Guess I'll hold off on buying some for now.