View Full Version : Calories burnt question.
Azure Wed, July 9th, 2008, 10:01 PM Alright, this has had me wondering for a while now.
Say I burn 2400 calories per day. Average of about 100 calories per hour. BMR rate. Without exercise, lifestyle, etc, etc factored in.
I know go on the treadmill, slow walk, for 30 min, and burn another 100 calories. Would that be on TOP of the 50 calories I ALREADY burn that half hour, or are those 50 calories included in the 100 that I burn during the 30 min on a treadmill.
Am I burning 200 calories that hour, or am I burning 150 calories that hour I guess is what I'm asking.
smuhhh Wed, July 9th, 2008, 10:12 PM I don't think you can look at it as adding the amount burned while doing cardio to what your body would have burned in a completely relaxed state. You are simply burning more calories while doing cardio that while sitting still. You are going to burn a different number of calories every day, every hour depending on so many factors. I wish I could construct a sentence with the point I have in my head... but alas I'm an idiot:D
Azure Wed, July 9th, 2008, 10:25 PM I was just throwing figures out there to explain what I meant.
Even if I only burn 30 calories that hour, if I walk on the treadmill, and burn 100 calories, I'm really only burning 70 calories through exercise. The rest is being burnt by my BMR.
zenpharaohs Wed, July 9th, 2008, 10:29 PM Alright, this has had me wondering for a while now.
Say I burn 2400 calories per day. Average of about 100 calories per hour. BMR rate. Without exercise, lifestyle, etc, etc factored in.
I know go on the treadmill, slow walk, for 30 min, and burn another 100 calories. Would that be on TOP of the 50 calories I ALREADY burn that half hour, or are those 50 calories included in the 100 that I burn during the 30 min on a treadmill.
Am I burning 200 calories that hour, or am I burning 150 calories that hour I guess is what I'm asking.
What you want to do is get a heart rate monitor, and run a baseline for that time of day on a rest day. Then on the day when you do the exercise, you can compare Calories burned and see how much difference the exercise made.
kevin_in_ga Wed, July 9th, 2008, 11:35 PM The answer is yes - the total calories you burn while exercising includes your basal caloric burn rate. As Zen said, you simply determine it on a rest day and subtract it out.
You are beginning to split hairs though - just make sure you are really pushing your heart rate up while doing your cardio, and take the total burned as exercise. If you want to factor it into a TDEE, just subtract 1 hr (or whatever total time you exercised) of your BMR and then add in the exercise calories estimated by your HRM.
Azure Thu, July 10th, 2008, 12:08 AM I'm kinda tight on money right now. Just bought a squat rack and some more weights, so the HRM is going to have to wait.
But I think I got my answer. Thanks guys!
|
|