banderbe
June 4th, 2007, 09:43 AM
If it is true that one cannot build muscle while cutting fat, what should one do with respect to weight/rep progression while cutting?
If you can't build muscle then it stands to reason that you shouldn't be trying to lift more weight or reps with each lifting session.
Is this accurate?
if not what am i missing?
MannishBoy
June 4th, 2007, 10:40 AM
Strength isn't totally a function of added lean mass. There is a significant portion of strength gains, particularly at a young "training age" that are due to nervous systems learning to activate more muscle fibers and fire them more efficiently.
Your strength gains may be a bit slower, but I never have as a goal to only equal my last workout. I'm always trying to put more on the bar, do one more rep, do one more set, or shorten my rests to increase density.
banderbe
June 4th, 2007, 10:50 AM
Strength isn't totally a function of added lean mass. There is a significant portion of strength gains, particularly at a young "training age" that are due to nervous systems learning to activate more muscle fibers and fire them more efficiently.
Your strength gains may be a bit slower, but I never have as a goal to only equal my last workout. I'm always trying to put more on the bar, do one more rep, do one more set, or shorten my rests to increase density.
Have you ever had a "bad" workout, where you went and simply could not lift more or do another rep than the last time you were at the gym?
That was me last night. Although I think I screwed myself by not eating a good pre-workout meal.
chris0374
June 4th, 2007, 10:52 AM
You should always try to improve the perfomance of your workouts, regardless of whether you are cutting or bulking. When you are cutting, your body needs a reason to keep it's muscle mass. By lifting heavy and trying to improve all the time, your body will have its reason to keep its muscle mass.
MannishBoy
June 4th, 2007, 10:57 AM
Everybody has those if they train long enough :nod: That's why I used the word "goal" above...sometimes you just have a bad day for whatever reason.
I'm not one to cut on extremely low calories, so maybe that helps to continue getting stronger, too.
Also, even if you are at a caloric deficit, you can still sometime add a bit of lean mass, especially if you are a beginner and don't have your calories through the floor.
zipeee
June 4th, 2007, 07:50 PM
If it is true that one cannot build muscle while cutting fat, what should one do with respect to weight/rep progression while cutting?
If you can't build muscle then it stands to reason that you shouldn't be trying to lift more weight or reps with each lifting session.
Is this accurate?
if not what am i missing?
Unless you are a fat beginner, a previously fit lifter coming off from a layoff (via muscle memory), or on drugs, you are unlikely to gain muscle mass while on a hypocaloric diet. Of course the nervous system can improve and give strength gains.